OnlineCull compared with Lightroom, Photo Mechanic, FastRawViewer and darktable

Culling is one step in a longer job, and the honest answer to “which tool should I use” depends entirely on which step you are on. All four of these are good at something this one is not, and two of them cost nothing. What follows is where each differs, where it is plainly the better choice, and the one narrow job this tool is built to do better than any of them.

Every factual claim below is read off the product’s own documentation and carries a link to the page it came from, with the date it was read. Nothing here is quoted from a review or from memory, and no price on this page is a number invented about somebody else’s software.

The four differences that matter

Third-party facts verified on 2026-11-08 against each product’s own documentation, linked in full below. OnlineCull’s own column is held by this repository’s checks rather than by a source link.
OnlineCullAdobe LightroomPhoto MechanicFastRawViewerdarktable
Runs onA web page, no installDesktop, mobile and webDesktop app (macOS, Windows)Desktop app (macOS, Windows)Desktop (Win, Linux, macOS)
PriceFree, no paid tierSubscription from $11.99/moFrom $149/yr, or $299 onceOne-off $23.99Free, GPL 3.0
Your photosStay on your machineCloud-synced, 1TB includedStay on your computerStay on your computerStay on your computer
EditingNone — culling onlyFull raw editorIngest and metadata, not rawViewer, no raw developmentFull raw developer

Should you use Adobe Lightroom instead?

The raw editor and catalogue most of the industry is organised around, and the one almost every reader will already have in mind.

What Adobe Lightroom does better

  • Developing the raw file once you have chosen it, which this tool does not attempt at all
  • Keeping one catalogue of everything you have ever shot
  • Masking, presets, lens corrections and everything else a raw developer is for
  • Being the format every lab, client and collaborator already expects

Use Adobe Lightroom, not this, when…

You are going to edit the photographs, not merely choose them — which is almost everybody, eventually. Nothing here replaces a raw developer, and this tool is built to hand off to one rather than to compete with it.

And stay here when…

You are at the stage before that: a card or a folder full of frames, most of which will never be edited, and the job is to find the keepers quickly. Importing a shoot into a catalogue in order to decide which tenth of it you want is work you can skip, and skipping it is the whole idea.

The facts, and where they were read

Runs on
Desktop, mobile and web. Its own page describes "Lightroom for mobile, desktop, and web, plus Lightroom Classic", the last being the one "optimized for desktop use" and included in the same plan. Source, read 2026-11-08.
Price
A subscription rather than a purchase: the page quotes an annual plan "starting at US$11.99/mo for the Annual, billed monthly plan or US$119.88/yr". Source, read 2026-11-08.
Your photos
Synced across devices by design — "The Adobe Lightroom plan comes with 1TB" of cloud storage — while Lightroom Classic, in the same plan, is the desktop-oriented one. Source, read 2026-11-08.
Editing
A full raw editor and library: its own page describes it as letting you "edit and organize your photos across desktop, mobile, and web". Source, read 2026-11-08.

Adobe Lightroom’s own site

Should you use Photo Mechanic instead?

The professional culling and ingest tool, and the one this tool borrows its central trick from — pulling the camera-rendered JPEG straight out of the raw container instead of demosaicing it.

What Photo Mechanic does better

  • Ingesting straight from cards, with renaming and folder structure, which this tool does not do
  • Metadata at professional scale, including captioning and reverse geocoding
  • Delivery workflows for press and sport, where it has been the standard for a long time
  • Working on shoots far larger than a browser tab should be asked to hold

Use Photo Mechanic, not this, when…

Culling is your job rather than a step in it. If you are shooting events weekly, captioning for a wire, or ingesting from several cards a day, it does things this tool deliberately does not and the licence pays for itself quickly.

And stay here when…

You cull occasionally, or you are on a machine you cannot install software on — a borrowed laptop, a locked-down work machine, a computer at a client site. The part of its speed that comes from reading the embedded preview is the part this tool copies, and that part is free.

The facts, and where they were read

Runs on
A desktop app you install: its page states macOS "OS X 10.10 or higher" and "64-bit Windows 7, 8, or 10". Source, read 2026-11-08.
Price
Paid, with both models offered: "$14.99* then every month" or "$149.00* then every year", or a perpetual licence at "$299.00" including "1 year of updates and support", after a trial that is "Free for 30 days" with "no payment info required". Source, read 2026-11-08.
Your photos
Stay on your computer — it is an installed application, not a service. Source, read 2026-11-08.
Editing
Built around ingest, metadata and delivery rather than around developing raw files — its feature list runs to "Ingest from Selection", metadata handling and reverse geocoding. Source, read 2026-11-08.

Photo Mechanic’s own site

Should you use FastRawViewer instead?

A small paid desktop viewer built for exactly this stage of the job, and the reason nobody should believe culling software has to be expensive.

What FastRawViewer does better

  • Showing you the real raw rendering, where this tool shows you the preview the camera made — a genuine difference when you are judging exposure at the edges
  • Reading a card or a disk without an import step, at desktop speed
  • Working on files too large or too many for a browser tab

Use FastRawViewer, not this, when…

You want to judge exposure and recoverable highlights from the raw data itself, not from the camera’s JPEG rendering of it. That is a real distinction and it is the thing this tool cannot do, because the browser has no raw developer in it.

And stay here when…

Judging the frame, rather than judging the exposure, is what you are doing — or you simply want to start now, on this machine, without buying or installing anything. The camera-rendered preview is what you shot and usually what you are choosing between.

The facts, and where they were read

Runs on
A desktop app, stated on its own page as running on "macOS (10.13+)" and "Windows (7-11, 64 bits)". Source, read 2026-11-08.
Price
Paid, and inexpensive: "$23.99", with a licence that "allows you to use the software on two (2) computers simultaneously" across both platforms, after a "fully functional 30-day trial". Source, read 2026-11-08.
Your photos
Stay on your computer — it is an installed application, not a service. Source, read 2026-11-08.
Editing
A viewer rather than a developer, and its distinguishing feature is that it renders the actual raw data rather than the embedded JPEG the camera wrote. Source, read 2026-11-08.

FastRawViewer’s own site

Should you use darktable instead?

The free software raw developer, and the answer when the objection to Lightroom is the subscription.

What darktable does better

  • Developing raw files for nothing, with no subscription and no account
  • Keeping a local catalogue that remains yours and readable
  • Being free software, so it cannot be repriced or withdrawn out from under you

Use darktable, not this, when…

You want to develop your raw files and you do not want to rent the software. It will do everything after the choosing, and it costs nothing — so there is no reason to treat the two tools as rivals.

And stay here when…

The step you are on is still the choosing, or you are not at your own computer. Its lighttable can cull, but it is a module in a program you install and import into; this is a page you open.

The facts, and where they were read

Runs on
A desktop app, with builds for Windows, Linux and macOS — the macOS bundles "support macOS versions starting with 13.5 (Ventura)", and currently for Apple silicon only, with "no official releases for Intel Macs". Source, read 2026-11-08.
Price
Free and open source, "released under the GPL 3.0". Source, read 2026-11-08.
Your photos
Stay on your computer — it is an installed application, not a service. Source, read 2026-11-08.
Editing
A full raw developer and asset manager, described on its own site as "an open source digital lighttable and darkroom". Source, read 2026-11-08.

darktable’s own site

How this page is kept honest

Comparison pages go wrong in a predictable way: a rival reprices, or changes its licence, and the page keeps saying what used to be true — usually in the author’s favour, because nobody re-reads the parts that flatter them. This page had that fault before it existed: the home page priced desktop culling apps at “$100+”, and FastRawViewer, which is one, is listed above at a fraction of it. The number is gone from the home page and the sourced prices are here.

So the facts are stored as individual claims, each with the page it was read from and the date, and the build fails once any one of them goes unverified for a quarter. That does not make them true; it makes them auditable, and it puts a deadline on the next read.

If something here is out of date or simply wrong, saying so is welcome and it will be corrected rather than argued with. The about page has the address.

Pages read, all on the products’ own sites: home.camerabits.com/get-photomechanic/ · home.camerabits.com/photo-mechanic/ · www.adobe.com/products/photoshop-lightroom.html · www.darktable.org/ · www.darktable.org/install/ · www.fastrawviewer.com/

Questions people actually ask

Is there a free alternative to Photo Mechanic for culling photos?
This is one for the culling step itself, and it uses the same central trick: both read the full-size JPEG the camera already wrote inside the raw file, rather than demosaicing the raw to show you a thumbnail. What Photo Mechanic has that this does not is card ingest, professional metadata work and the capacity for shoots far larger than a browser tab should hold.
Can I cull RAW files without installing anything?
Yes. This runs as a web page in an up-to-date Chromium browser, opens a folder through the File System Access API and reads the previews locally. Nothing is uploaded and nothing is installed, which is what makes it usable on a borrowed or locked-down machine where you could not install a desktop app at all.
Do my photos get uploaded anywhere?
No, and not as a policy that could quietly change: there is no upload endpoint on the site, so it could not receive them. Your files are opened locally and parsed in the browser, and your ratings are written to XMP sidecar files beside the originals, which are never modified. You can confirm all of it in your own network inspector.
Should I use this instead of Lightroom?
Not instead — before. Lightroom develops raw files and this does not attempt to, so the honest shape is to choose the keepers here and edit them there. The ratings travel as XMP sidecars, which Lightroom reads.
What is this tool bad at?
Three things, plainly. It cannot develop, crop or convert a photograph. It shows the camera’s own rendering rather than the raw data, so judging recoverable highlights is better done in a raw viewer. And a browser tab has limits a desktop app does not, so a very large shoot is work for installed software.

Back to the culler